Offseason Game: Rank that Logo!

[kievthegreat]

Seeing as the Devils have released a much talked about rebrand, I thought it would be fun to tap into the collective hive mind and see how much we like respective logos! I will compile to a rating afterwards.

Simply rank each logo in order from 1-10

Belfast:

 

Cardiff:



Coventry:


Dundee:


Fife:



Glasgow:


Guildford:



Manchester:



Nottingham:


Squealers:



PS. All pictures are from the teams page on the EIHL website. For some reason the Devils picture was uploaded at twice the size.

PPS. Picked an alternate file for the Dundee logo because the file on the EIHL website has the white bits inside the logo as transparent.

PPPS. The Stars logo on the EIHL and on their own page are the inverse of each other, I have taken the white one that is on their shirts.

[pantherlee]

1. Steelers
2. Panthers
3. Blaze
4. Clan
5. Storm
6. Devils
7. Giants
8. Flyers
9. Stars
10. Flames (Calgary Flames rip off)

[kievthegreat]

1: Glasgow (it's probably a bit too Braveheart, but I still like it)
2: Fife (quite like the simple and old design)
3. Dundee (quite plain, but I do still quite like it)
4. Squealers (obviously I hate them, but objectively I think it's an alright logo)
5: Manchester (really like the border, but hate the figure in it.)
6. Nottingham (they've tried to go for a 3D element of the Panther leaping out, but because only the claws break the boundaries of the shield, the Panther looks even more like it's been flattened)
7. Belfast (it's just a guy with headband on. Plus I really don't like the colour palette)
8. Cardiff (I can't unsee the penguin)
9. Coventry (Why is there a fire breathing goat?)
10. Guildford (I can't reward plagiarism with anything other than last place)

[Yotes]

I'm distinctly meh about all ten, but still:

1. Fife - some traditional charm.
2. Guildford - a rip off, but at least it's nice and simple.
3. Dundee - rather dull but inoffensive.
4. Sheffield - the girder bit works quite well. The steelworker not so much.
5. Nottingham - obese panther isn't the worst of the ten.
6. Cardiff - hope they didn't spend too much money on it.
7. Belfast - I get that it's a difficult name to represent, but why He Man?
8. Manchester - decide on one badge and use it, rather than combining the two.
9. Glasgow - sorry Kiev, but the Mel Gibson redesign didn't do much for me. I preferred that weird one they used to have.
10. Coventry - a fairly dull picture of a dragon to begin with, then some idiot bungs the ugliest wordmark in history on the bottom. Terrible.

I'd score them all bottom half if I could though.

[kievthegreat]

Aug 4, 2023 15:25:15 GMT Yotes said:

I'm distinctly meh about all ten, but still:

1. Fife - some traditional charm.
2. Guildford - a rip off, but at least it's nice and simple.
3. Dundee - rather dull but inoffensive.
4. Sheffield - the girder bit works quite well. The steelworker not so much.
5. Nottingham - obese panther isn't the worst of the ten.
6. Cardiff - hope they didn't spend too much money on it.
7. Belfast - I get that it's a difficult name to represent, but why He Man?
8. Manchester - decide on one badge and use it, rather than combining the two.
9. Glasgow - sorry Kiev, but the Mel Gibson redesign didn't do much for me. I preferred that weird one they used to have.
10. Coventry - a fairly dull picture of a dragon to begin with, then some idiot bungs the ugliest wordmark in history on the bottom. Terrible.

I'd score them all bottom half if I could though.

I can understanding not liking Mel, but thinking it's worse than this:



A truly horrific take IMHO.


I will agree though, that most of the logos deserve bottom half.

[pantherlee]

Aug 4, 2023 15:25:15 GMT Yotes said:

I'm distinctly meh about all ten, but still:

1. Fife - some traditional charm.
2. Guildford - a rip off, but at least it's nice and simple.
3. Dundee - rather dull but inoffensive.
4. Sheffield - the girder bit works quite well. The steelworker not so much.
5. Nottingham - obese panther isn't the worst of the ten.
6. Cardiff - hope they didn't spend too much money on it.
7. Belfast - I get that it's a difficult name to represent, but why He Man?
8. Manchester - decide on one badge and use it, rather than combining the two.
9. Glasgow - sorry Kiev, but the Mel Gibson redesign didn't do much for me. I preferred that weird one they used to have.
10. Coventry - a fairly dull picture of a dragon to begin with, then some idiot bungs the ugliest wordmark in history on the bottom. Terrible.

I'd score them all bottom half if I could though.

I think Belfast is more Wella shampoo than He-Man

[Yotes]

Aug 4, 2023 15:30:41 GMT kievthegreat said:

A truly horrific take IMHO.

🤣 I will admit I'd not quite remembered that it had two of those creepy looking dudes on it.

[Jono Bullard]

1. There
2. is
3. no
4. point
5. ranking
6. logo's
7. it's
8. your
9. opinion
10. Steelers