The Cat's Whiskers 2010/11 Panthers Season Review

[Deleted]

TCW Columnist Greg Mitchell, TCW contributor Paul Balm and TCW Live's Jono Bullard & Iain Dilley all review the Panthers 2010/11 season and mark each player out of 10.

Constructive comments and debate is welcomed

The Cat's Whiskers 2010/11 Panthers Season Review

[bill238]

good article, I agree with the almost all the ratings but not the corey neilson one and especially the billy ryan one, IMO he was one of our best players this year and I will be hugely dissapointed if he doesn't stay at panthers next season, he has great agility and is extremely skillfull and I love watching him play, I would have rated him 8 or 9/10

[BigLad]

Damn good read. Little harsh on the Corey write-up though!

[iginla]

Mmmm good read,but i agree with Big Lad,a bit harsh on Corey there boys.

You seem to have marked him for his coaching rather than just as a player.

[panthers4ever]

Great read guys

[No 29]

Good reviews of the season.

The only one I disagree with was Beauregard - I don't think his work rate made up for his lack of points. Great last two matches but he didn't score a point in 15 of the other 23 games against the top 3. I know he had a lot more ice time at Manchester but I expected more production than we got this year.

[Paul]

Apr 12, 2011 21:11:26 GMT iginla said:

Mmmm good read,but i agree with Big Lad,a bit harsh on Corey there boys.

You seem to have marked him for his coaching rather than just as a player.

I can't vouch for the other three but I know that my appraisal of Neilson was split into two - coach and player. It looks as though Jono has amalgamated the two and then averaged my scores.

At the end of the day they're just our opinions but I stand by mine and what I said. I worry about Neilson's lapses as a defenceman and I think he has been tactically naive as a coach for a lot of the last three years. If he wants to improve he's got to start looking at where mistakes were made, admit that they were and learn from them.