All Star Team 2010/11

[Pies]

As anyone who watches the Elite League show will know, Simmsey has done his all star team for this year and tweeted that he feels there are no stars in Nottingham, Coventry or Belfast. He's asked people to e-mail their choices in but i thought it'd be intresting to see who's in the cage's all star team. 1 goalie, 2 d men and 3 forwards - I figure we can do an import all star team and a British all star team

Import

Kowalski
Nikolav - K Smith
Legue - Pelle - Ryan

British
Lyle
M. Richardson - Meyers
Clarke - S. Smith - Tait

[Rob Scott]

KSP
Neilson Zion
Galbraith Liscak McDonald


Green
Norton Meyers
Ward Levers Soar

[sambo79]

Tendler from Hull - look at his points considering the team he's on. Has to be the player of the season surely?

[texpef]

pretty simple regards brits as there aint many..
Murphy
richardson weaver
tait shields peacock

imports is trickier..

Kowalski
weller lepine
pelle lambert matzka

[GiantsFan00]

Mar 3, 2011 12:49:34 GMT sambo79 said:

Tendler from Hull - look at his points considering the team he's on. Has to be the player of the season surely?

Was thinking about this myself and this season it's pretty hard to narrow it down as there are a range of players for each position. Simms team just screamed Ragan Bias as Strachan tactfully pointed out.

[rangers]

import:

Mustakovs

Weller
K Smith

Rzutsko(sp) (4th highest goals per game in the league and he plays for Vipers!)
Tendler
Pelle


Brits

Murphy
Weaver
Richardson
Peacock
Myers
Tait

[killercarlson]

Import

Muskothingy
Weller - Hoffman
Tendler - Simon - Galbraith

British

Lyle
Richardson - Weaver
Clarke - Dowd - Tait

[ted logan]

Imports

K-Wall (just ahead of Moose as IMHO he is a better NM than Moose who has the benefit of a better D corps)

Weller - Lepine

Tendler - Pelle - Legue

Brits

Murphy

Lee - Weaver (picked Lee as a physical stay at home type D-man to compliment Weaver's more attacking/play-making style)

Tait - Myers - Clarke

[Robbie Nud]

Cannot believe that no-one has picked Lacho!!

Brits
Lyle
Lee - Weaver
Lacho - Clarke - Tait

Imports
Mustakovs
Weller - Lepine
Bellamy - Pelle - simon

[jambros1]

Imports

K-Wall -performed well with virtually no D support

Weller - Lepine

Tendler - Pelle - Legue

Brits

Murphy

Richardson - Weaver

Tait - Myers - Clarke

[pantherdman]

K-wall
Lepine - Weller
Penner - Pelle - Cook

Lyle
Meyers - Weaver
Shields - Myers - Tait

[BigLad]

Kowalski
Weller - Lepine
Tait - Shields - Clarke

Murphy
Weaver - Richardson
Pelle - Simon - Ryan

[Jasper]

Imports:

K-Wall
Neilson, Weller
Pelle, Galbraith, Simon

Brits:

Murphy
Meyers, Weaver
Clarke, Myers, Dowd

Only Panthers fans could fail to vote for one of their own even given that he has scored 40 goals, 73 points and lies 6th in the league in points and third in goals. Streets ahead of Peacock and Shields.

Oh sorry, I forgot people want Clarke to skate and hit like Bellamy, pass like Galbraith, fight like Lepine and never shoot a one timer over the bar. I've got news for you folks, if he could do that he wouldn't be playing over here. Just like every player over here, he has weaknesses, accept him for what he does.

[pantherdman]

Got any +/- figures?

[maddylan]

kowalski

weller lepine

legue pelle ryan



murphy

meyers weaver

clarke myers dowd

[Jasper]

Mar 3, 2011 20:23:20 GMT pantherdman said:

Got any +/- figures?

Obviously not seeing as you know very well there are none published but that's exactly my point - accept him for the 40 goals he's scored (better than all but two players in the league) and realise that that if he was as good defensively as Molin, Richardson or Kalmikov for example he probably wouldn't be here.

There are players with fewer goals and points than Clarke that are just as bad/worse defensively.

[pantherdman]

I get your point, Clarke is an excellent finisher, the title of the thread is All star Team, most people are naming an all star line.

i would have Clarke in my squad (if I had to abide by the inport limit).

he is a frustrating player Clarke, I think we are critical because he could be awesome.

[iginla]

Kowalski

Weller Jacobsen

Simon Benedict Pelle


Murphy

Weaver Meyers

Clarke Myers Dowd

[barthez]

Kowalski

weller lepine

tendler pelle simon

murphy

weaver meyers

clarke tait peacock

[sambo79]

Mar 3, 2011 21:12:03 GMT pantherdman said:

I get your point, Clarke is an excellent finisher, the title of the thread is All star Team, most people are naming an all star line.

i would have Clarke in my squad (if I had to abide by the inport limit).

he is a frustrating player Clarke, I think we are critical because he could be awesome.

And as has been pointed out. If he had the other attributes people are clamouring for - he wouldn't be playing in this country and we certainly couldn't afford to pay him.

He's probably one of the top highest earners in the entire league. If he was any better he'd be too expensive!

[Carnell]

Moose

Weller Lepine

Simon Pelle Tendler

Murphy

Meyers Weaver

Clarke Peacock Tait

[Bruins33]

Import

Kowalski
Hoffman - Lepine
Bellamy - Simon - Weller (or Hoffman, both seem to have played forward before)
Brit

Lyle
Lee - Richardson
Lacho - Myers - Shields