|
|
Post by kievthegreat on Jan 31, 2020 17:04:53 GMT
As the league campaign is all but over and we're starting to think about next year, thought it would be interesting to see who we want to keep. To keep it as straightforward as possible, just answer "yes/no/maybe" on whether Panthers should keep them. Obviously someone like Herr might get a better offer, but if you want to keep him still put "yes" if you'd want to keep him.
Template:
Carr -
Whistle -
Gospel -
Fick -
Desantis -
Matheson -
Lepine -
Connelly -
Tetlow -
Deutsch -
Lacho -
Perlini -
Hazeldine -
Kelsall -
Malmquist -
Golovkovs -
Hansen -
Horvat -
Herr -
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot -
Betteridge -
Rheault -
Bulmer -
*seems a bit unfair to give him any rating ATM
|
|
|
|
Post by kievthegreat on Jan 31, 2020 17:10:45 GMT
Carr - Maybe
Whistle - Yes
Gospel - Yes
Fick - Yes
Desantis - Yes
Matheson - Yes
Lepine - No
Connelly - Yes
Tetlow - Yes
Deutsch - Yes
Lacho - Maybe
Perlini - Yes
Hazeldine - Yes
Kelsall - Yes
Malmquist - Maybe
Golovkovs - Maybe
Hansen - Yes
Horvat - Yes
Herr - Yes
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot - Yes
Betteridge - Yes
Rheault - No
Bulmer - Yes
Only one I think will be contentious is Horvat, I like what he brings on his current line, especially considering he's not had much opportunity with better players. Something tells me without Lacho as a linemate he could provide more offense. I'd also consider going Whistle as starting netminder. Especially with 1 less import next year and what I think is a weak Panthers Britpack. If we could get Farmer back, or poach Ferrara I'd move Lacho to "no" and give his minutes to Kelsall.
|
|
|
|
Post by PantherB on Jan 31, 2020 18:52:54 GMT
Carr - Maybe
Whistle - Yes
Gospel - Yes
Fick - Yes
Desantis - No
Matheson - Yes*
Lepine - Maybe
Connelly - Yes
Tetlow - Yes
Deutsch - Maybe
Lacho - No
Perlini - Yes
Hazeldine - Yes
Kelsall - Yes
Malmquist - Maybe
Golovkovs - No
Hansen - Yes*
Horvat - Yes
Herr - Yes*
Tousignant - N/A
Talbot - Yes*
Betteridge - Yes
Rheault - No
Bulmer - Yes
For the Maybe's, if we can upgrade then I won't be fussed if they leave.
Desantis and Golovkovs, I don't think either are bad, but I feel we can definitely upgrade. I wouldn't want to swap Golovkovs for someone who can't skate well, would want someone with similar speed.
Rheault and Lachowicz, not much needs to be said to justify the No.
Players with * next to their names are key re-signings for me. I excluded British players from that as Brits are essentially key re-signings anyway.
|
|
|
|
Post by wgray on Jan 31, 2020 22:03:45 GMT
Carr - Maybe
Whistle - Yes
Gospel - Maybe
Fick - Yes (He’ll be here anyway, 2nd year of MBA)
Matheson - Yes
Connelly - Yes
Tetlow - Yes
Deutsch - Yes
Lepine - Maybe
DeSantis - Maybe
Perlini - Yes
Hazeldine - Yes
Kelsall - Yes
Hansen - Yes
Herr - Yes
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot - Yes
Betteridge - Yes
Malmquist - Maybe
Golovkovs - Maybe
Horvat - Maybe
Bulmer - Maybe
Lacho - No
Rheault - No
For me, the maybes are players who I’d be happy to see back but if the team can be adjusted and ultimately improved with some different players then so be it.
Without wanting to confuse the situation we will also be at the mercy of the new roster restrictions next season. 13 imports, 4 O25 Brits and 3 U25 Brits.
This will make it quite difficult for Wallace, especially on defence.
|
|
|
|
Post by allingtonskates on Feb 1, 2020 1:25:11 GMT
Carr - Maybe
Whistle - yes
Gospel - yes
Fick - yes
Desantis - no
Matheson - yes
Lepine - maybe
Connelly - yes
Tetlow - yes
Deutsch - yes
Lacho - no
Perlini - yes
Hazeldine - yes
Kelsall - maybe
Malmquist - yes
Golovkovs - no
Hansen - yes
Horvat - yes
Herr - yes
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot - yes
Betteridge - yes
Rheault - no
Bulmer - yes
|
|
|
|
Post by ashfieldpanther on Feb 1, 2020 8:35:42 GMT
As the league campaign is all but over and we're starting to think about next year, thought it would be interesting to see who we want to keep. To keep it as straightforward as possible, just answer "yes/no/maybe" on whether Panthers should keep them. Obviously someone like Herr might get a better offer, but if you want to keep him still put "yes" if you'd want to keep him. Template: Carr - no Whistle - yes Gospel - no Fick - no Desantis - no Matheson - yes Lepine - no Connelly - yes Tetlow - no Deutsch - yes Lacho - yes Perlini - yes Hazeldine - yes Kelsall - yes Malmquist - no Golovkovs - no Hansen - no Horvat - yes Herr - yes Tousignant - N/A* Talbot - yes Betteridge - yes Rheault - no Bulmer - no *seems a bit unfair to give him any rating ATM |
|
The Flying Shirt
Paul Adey
Adam #7 #47 - Forever #1
Posts: 6,624
Member is Online
|
Post by The Flying Shirt on Feb 1, 2020 12:10:00 GMT
One less import and one less Brit. The struggling teams will safe money and the Arena teams will either put the saving into better players or trouser the money in sunnier places. On that basis foolishly hoping for upgrades what I would like is:
Carr - No
Whistle - Yes
Gospel - No
Fick - Yes
Desantis - No
Matheson - Yes
Lepine - Yes
Connelly - Yes
Tetlow - Yes
Deutsch - Yes
Lacho - Yes
Perlini - Yes
Hazeldine - No
Kelsall - No
Malmquist - Yes
Golovkovs - No
Hansen - Yes
Horvat - Yes
Herr - Yes
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot - Yes
Betteridge - Yes
Rheault - No
Bulmer - Depends on the next few weeks
|
|
|
|
Post by jd on Feb 1, 2020 13:16:03 GMT
Carr - maybe
Whistle - yes
Gospel - maybe - yes got to play for me
Fick - no
Desantis - maybe
Matheson - yes
Lepine - no
Connelly - yes
Tetlow - yes
Deutsch - yes
Lacho - no
Perlini - yes
Hazeldine - yes
Kelsall - yes
Malmquist - no
Golovkovs - no
Hansen - yes
Horvat - yes
Herr - yes
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot - yes
Betteridge - yes
Rheault - no
Bulmer - yes
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 1, 2020 13:42:09 GMT
Carr - maybe Whistle - yes Gospel - maybe - yes got to play for me Fick - no Desantis - maybe Matheson - yes Lepine - no Connelly - yes Tetlow - yes Deutsch - yes Lacho - no Perlini - yes Hazeldine - yes Kelsall - yes Malmquist - no Golovkovs - no Hansen - yes Horvat - yes Herr - yes Tousignant - N/A* Talbot - yes Betteridge - yes Rheault - no Bulmer - yes Same potentially although Fick will be back cause of uni |
|
|
|
Post by dill1015 on Feb 1, 2020 16:37:04 GMT
Carr - yes
Whistle - no
Gospel - yes
Fick - yes
Desantis - yes
Matheson - no
Lepine - no
Connelly - no
Tetlow - yes
Deutsch - yes
Lacho - strongest no possible
Perlini - yes
Hazeldine - yes
Kelsall - yes
Malmquist - maybe
Golovkovs - no
Hansen - yes
Horvat - no
Herr - yes
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot - yes
Betteridge - yes
Rheault - no
Bulmer - no
|
|
|
|
Post by pantherlee on Feb 1, 2020 20:35:42 GMT
Carr - yes Whistle - no Gospel - yes Fick - yes Desantis - yes Matheson - no Lepine - no Connelly - no Tetlow - yes Deutsch - yes Lacho - strongest no possible Perlini - yes Hazeldine - yes Kelsall - yes Malmquist - maybe Golovkovs - no Hansen - yes Horvat - no Herr - yes Tousignant - N/A* Talbot - yes Betteridge - yes Rheault - no Bulmer - no No to Matheson and Connelly?? |
|
|
|
Post by jd on Feb 1, 2020 21:34:10 GMT
Carr - yes Whistle - no Gospel - yes Fick - yes Desantis - yes Matheson - no Lepine - no Connelly - no Tetlow - yes Deutsch - yes Lacho - strongest no possible Perlini - yes Hazeldine - yes Kelsall - yes Malmquist - maybe Golovkovs - no Hansen - yes Horvat - no Herr - yes Tousignant - N/A* Talbot - yes Betteridge - yes Rheault - no Bulmer - no No to Matheson and Connelly?? Eh?? |
|
Yotes
Forum Admin 
Posts: 16,383
|
Post by Yotes on Feb 1, 2020 22:01:25 GMT
Isn't Whistle younger, or same age, as Gospel? I think the latter's time has come and gone personally.
|
|
|
|
Post by dill1015 on Feb 1, 2020 22:27:48 GMT
Carr - yes Whistle - no Gospel - yes Fick - yes Desantis - yes Matheson - no Lepine - no Connelly - no Tetlow - yes Deutsch - yes Lacho - strongest no possible Perlini - yes Hazeldine - yes Kelsall - yes Malmquist - maybe Golovkovs - no Hansen - yes Horvat - no Herr - yes Tousignant - N/A* Talbot - yes Betteridge - yes Rheault - no Bulmer - no No to Matheson and Connelly?? Dont think either have been bad at all. Matherson has been far better than i thought, but he'll be 37 and i think we need to freshen up the squad. At some point it'll be a season too far. Connelly has been solid but thought we'd get more production out of him. Wouldnt be gutted if either signed though. |
|
fyfe
Jade Galbraith
Posts: 63
|
Post by fyfe on Feb 3, 2020 9:32:32 GMT
My picks:
Carr - Yes
Whistle - Yes
Gospel - No
Fick - Yes
Desantis - No
Matheson - Yes
Lepine - No
Connelly - Yes
Tetlow - Yes
Deutsch - Yes
Lacho - Yes
Perlini - Yes
Hazeldine - Yes
Kelsall - Yes
Malmquist - Yes
Golovkovs - No
Hansen - Yes
Horvat - No
Herr - Yes
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot - Yes
Betteridge - Yes
Rheault - No
Bulmer - No
I would also keep an eye on the coach situation in DEL2 in case there is a change and Farmer becomes available cause would add him back. Also would give Kelsall more ice time.
|
|
nottinghamsenator
Robert Lachowicz
How much wood could a Tkachuk chuck if a Tkachuk could chuck wood?
Posts: 424
|
Post by nottinghamsenator on Feb 3, 2020 10:00:06 GMT
Carr - Yes
Whistle - Yes
Gospel - No
Fick - Yes
Desantis - No
Matheson - Yes
Lepine - No
Connelly - Yes
Tetlow - Yes
Deutsch - Maybe
Lacho - Maybe
Perlini - Yes
Hazeldine - Yes
Kelsall - Yes
Malmquist - Yes
Golovkovs - Maybe
Hansen - Yes
Horvat - No
Herr - Yes
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot - Yes
Betteridge - Yes
Rheault - No
Bulmer - No
|
|
|
|
Post by bobness on Feb 3, 2020 11:26:15 GMT
Easier to say it like this.
Yes - All the Brits, and Panthers need to get a(nother) premier scoring Brit. Offer Ferrara or Long a wedge to come here. I'd like to see Ollie in the top 9 if not the top 6. I'm basing this on the assumption that Lacho will leave over the summer.
I'd like Panthers to keep Herr, but that would be a minor miracle. Hansen and Malmqvist get a yes. I wouldn't say no to Talbot, but he may well retire. Fick and Connelly have done the business so far, Matheson might retire, if not, he'd be OK, especially if he can manage his icetime better.
No - All the rest. Replaceable/upgrade-able/not shown enough consistency.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 3, 2020 11:36:01 GMT
Simple question .. if Herr was a devils player would you expect them to retain him?
|
|
Gilly
Ashley Tait
Posts: 1,870
|
Post by Gilly on Feb 3, 2020 12:07:46 GMT
it all depends if there are better options out there who become available during the summer.
But, purely based on this season if no better players are available:
Template:
Carr - Yes
Whistle - Yes
Gospel - Yes
Fick - Yes
Desantis - Maybe
Matheson - Yes
Lepine - Maybe
Connelly - Yes
Tetlow - Yes
Deutsch - Maybe
Lacho - No
Perlini - Yes
Hazeldine - Yes
Kelsall - Maybe
Malmquist - Maybe
Golovkovs - No
Hansen - Yes
Horvat - Yes
Herr - Yes
Tousignant - So Far Yes
Talbot - Yes
Betteridge - Yes
Rheault - NO NO NO NO NO
Bulmer - No
|
|
|
|
Post by bobness on Feb 3, 2020 12:31:49 GMT
Simple question .. if Herr was a devils player would you expect them to retain him? I'd expect them to try, same as I expect Panthers to. I don't think Cardiff have ever had a player quite as good in whole league terms. Kyle Baun/Patrick Dwyer (sadly now retired it seems) would be my comparators. Where Cardiff score is they very rarely get duff new signings. They always seem to get the player they need, be it an offensive dynamo (Haddad/Martin/Hedden) a reliable second line depth scorer (Pope/Bentivoglio/Ulmer) or a third line anchor. They very rarely trumpet players as something they turn out not to be. |
|
DMS
Robert Lachowicz
Posts: 573 
|
Post by DMS on Feb 3, 2020 15:16:20 GMT
Easier to say it like this. Yes - All the Brits, and Panthers need to get a(nother) premier scoring Brit. Offer Ferrara or Long a wedge to come here. I'd like to see Ollie in the top 9 if not the top 6. I'm basing this on the assumption that Lacho will leave over the summer. I'd like Panthers to keep Herr, but that would be a minor miracle. Hansen and Malmqvist get a yes. I wouldn't say no to Talbot, but he may well retire. Fick and Connelly have done the business so far, Matheson might retire, if not, he'd be OK, especially if he can manage his icetime better. No - All the rest. Replaceable/upgrade-able/not shown enough consistency. Matheson only OK?!? |
|
|
|
Post by bobness on Feb 3, 2020 16:30:06 GMT
Easier to say it like this. Yes - All the Brits, and Panthers need to get a(nother) premier scoring Brit. Offer Ferrara or Long a wedge to come here. I'd like to see Ollie in the top 9 if not the top 6. I'm basing this on the assumption that Lacho will leave over the summer. I'd like Panthers to keep Herr, but that would be a minor miracle. Hansen and Malmqvist get a yes. I wouldn't say no to Talbot, but he may well retire. Fick and Connelly have done the business so far, Matheson might retire, if not, he'd be OK, especially if he can manage his icetime better. No - All the rest. Replaceable/upgrade-able/not shown enough consistency. Matheson only OK?!? He's logged huge icetime this year, at times you can tell he's 36. He also leads the team in minuses, although he is also second on pluses (and both of those are related to his icetime). Whether he'd led on "minuses per 60 minutes of icetime" is another matter. I'd probably like to see him back if he can be guaranteed a smaller role. |
|
|
|
Post by PantherTom on Feb 3, 2020 16:42:00 GMT
Carr - YES
Whistle - YES
Gospel - YES
Fick - YES
Desantis - NO
Matheson - YES
Lepine - YES
Connelly - YES
Tetlow - YES
Deutsch - YES
Lacho - MAYBE
Perlini - YES
Hazeldine - YES
Kelsall - YES
Malmquist - YES
Golovkovs - NO
Hansen - YES
Horvat - YES
Herr - YES
Tousignant - YES if carries on his style of play
Talbot - YES
Betteridge - YES
Rheault - NO Would sell my season ticket if he came back again! Been a wage thief for 2 years!
Bulmer - YES
|
|
Pies
Forum Moderator 
Reluctant Chief of ITK
Posts: 4,879
|
Post by Pies on Feb 3, 2020 18:35:10 GMT
He's logged huge icetime this year, at times you can tell he's 36. He also leads the team in minuses, although he is also second on pluses (and both of those are related to his icetime). Whether he'd led on "minuses per 60 minutes of icetime" is another matter. I'd probably like to see him back if he can be guaranteed a smaller role. His legs might be slower than they were but his brain works quicker than anyone else’s in this league?! 4 points this weekend and double shifting. He’s in my top 3 to bring back. Top 2 even! |
|
deke
Robert Lachowicz
Posts: 421
|
Post by deke on Feb 6, 2020 8:21:50 GMT
Carr - maybe
Whistle - yes
Gospel - no
Fick - yes
Desantis - maybe
Matheson - maybe
Lepine - no
Connelly - no
Tetlow - yes
Deutsch - yes
Lacho - maybe
Perlini - yes
Hazeldine - yes
Kelsall - yes
Malmquist - yes
Golovkovs - yes
Hansen - yea
Horvat - maybe
Herr - yes!
Tousignant - N/A*
Talbot - yes
Betteridge - yes
Rheault - hell no
Bulmer - yes with the right line mates
|
|
